2008 2009 |
Arian Blanco |
Scene Stealer | Oscar Hijuelos | Scene Stealer |
| Thomas Ferriter | Scene Stealer | Teatro SEA | Icon Scene Stealer |
| April D. Harris, Esq. | Scene Stealer | Joseph G. Gonzal | Scene Stealer |
| CBS/Barbara Matos | Icon Legend | Karen Bardales | Icon |
| Lin Manuel Miranda | Icon | Leonel Urcuyo | Scene Stealer |
| Doris Silk | Legend | Suellen Urcuyo | Scene Stealer |
| Elsie C. Stark | Icon | Mark Carney | Legend |
| Access Talent | Scene Stealer | Francisco Soto | Icon |
| Recorded Books | Icon | Philip Lee | Star |
| Revolución Latina | Icon * Icon | ||
| Michael Palma | Scene Stealer |
| 2010 2011 |
| Joseph G Gonzal | Legend | Barbara Bennion | Scene Stealer |
| Lin Manuel Miranda | Icon | Barbara Matos | Icon |
| Carlos Barba | Icon | José Cheo Oliveras | Scene Stealer |
| Joanne Mazurki | Star |